Saved
Punk & post-punk

Joy as an Act of Resistance

Idles put the force of an abrasive band behind grief, solidarity and an argument against emotional repression.

Worth your time?Yes.Hear the whole thing.What works, what does not, who it is for ↓
2:07in production/ 2:07 · ceiling 15 min

The brief is written and checked. The video joins this page when it is cut.1 min read · 2:07 planned

Read the brief

Joy as an Act of Resistance is Idles' second album, released in 2018. After scrapping material that felt too dependent on repeating Brutalism, the band made vulnerability a central purpose. Joe Talbot's personal experiences sit beside songs addressing masculinity, immigration and class.

Worth your time?

Yes. Hear the whole thing.

What works
    What does not
      Hear it if
      • Listeners who want confrontational rock to make a direct communal appeal
      Skip it if
      • Listeners seeking subtle political language or a widely varied sonic palette
      Who should hear it, and who should skipHide who it is for
      The written brief1 min read

      What the record is and where it came from

      Joy as an Act of Resistance is Idles’ second album, released in 2018. After scrapping material that felt too dependent on repeating Brutalism, the band made vulnerability a central purpose. Joe Talbot’s personal experiences sit beside songs addressing masculinity, immigration and class.

      How it sounds, and how it was made

      Produced by Space and mixed by Adam Greenspan and Nick Launay, the record retains an abrasive, forceful band sound. Talbot’s delivery gives direct statements a confrontational physical presence. The tension is between that harsh presentation and an invitation to acknowledge dependence, grief and affection.

      What lands

      “Danny Nedelko” makes its account of immigration personal through a named friend. “June” addresses the death of Talbot’s daughter, bringing the argument for vulnerability into a specific and painful experience. Those particulars give the album more weight than its title could supply on its own.

      What does not

      The directness can flatten complex subjects into slogans, and the limited range of attack may make separate songs feel too similar. Listeners already sympathetic to the message may still want more ambiguity in its expression. Forceful affirmation does not always become persuasive observation.

      The ideas inside it

      Tenderness need not arrive in a gentle musical form. The album asks whether a language associated with aggression can make room for admitting hurt and valuing other people. Its most convincing answer comes from personal detail rather than a general declaration of good intentions.

      Who should hear it, and who should not

      Hear it if the shared release of a forceful rock performance matters to you. It is less suited to a preference for indirect social writing or a constantly changing arrangement palette.

      Is it worth your time

      Yes, with tolerance for bluntness. Hear the personal songs alongside the public declarations; they explain what the insistence is trying to protect.

      Same genre · Punk & post-punk4 of 91
      11:02
      Atrocity ExhibitionDanny Brown · 2016Atrocity Exhibition is Danny Brown’s third studio album, released in 2016 after signing with Warp Records. It is named after a Joy Division song. Paul White produced all tracks except ‘Really Doe’ (Black Milk), ‘Pneumonia’ (Evian Christ), and unspecified contributions from The Alchemist. Guest appearances include Kendrick Lamar, Ab-Soul, Earl Sweatshirt, B-Real, Kelela, and Petite Noir. The album draws stylistic influence from Talking Heads and Joy Division — and, while writing it, Brown also drew inspiration from Björk. It received continued critical acclaim but reduced commercial sales.
      10:34
      Ill CommunicationBeastie Boys · 1994Ill Communication is the Beastie Boys’ fourth studio album, co-produced by the band and Mario Caldato, Jr., recorded between 1993 and 1994 at Tin Pan Alley and G-Son Studios. It expands on their live-instrument approach begun with Check Your Head, incorporating hip-hop, punk rock, jazz, and funk, and reflects influences from Miles Davis’s On the Corner and Agharta. Contributions include live instrumentation from Money Mark, Eric Bobo, and Amery Smith, plus guest vocals from Q-Tip and Biz Markie. The 'Sabotage' backing track—built around MCA’s fuzzed and twangy bass—was laid down at Tin Pan Alley and sat unused for a year under the working title 'Chris Rock' before final vocals were added. The album was released on May 23, 1994, and received widespread critical acclaim for its stylistic range and synthesis of the group’s earlier impulses with matured musicianship and lyrical depth. Its artwork features a 1964 Bruce Davidson photograph and Alex Grey’s 'Gaia'.
      11:33
      Sandinista!The Clash · 1980A 36-song triple LP released in December 1980. The Clash’s fourth studio album. Recorded over most of 1980 across London, Manchester, Jamaica, and New York. Produced by the band — primarily Mick Jones and Joe Strummer — with Mikey Dread’s participation. The only Clash album where all four members perform lead vocals.
      10:27
      The IdiotIggy Pop · 1977The Idiot is Iggy Pop’s 1977 debut solo album, produced by David Bowie and recorded at Château d'Hérouville in France and Musicland Studios in Munich. Bowie composed most music and played keyboards, guitar, saxophone and drum machine; Pop wrote lyrics in real time and recorded vocals in Munich. French session musicians Laurent Thibault and Michel Santangeli contributed bass and drums, with Santangeli’s parts retained despite his early dismissal. The album’s sound is mechanical, sparse and emotionally detached—a fusion of James Brown’s funk and Kraftwerk’s electronics. It has influenced post-punk, electronic and industrial artists.
      Up next in Music

      Kala

      M.I.A. · 2007 · 2:00

      M.I.A. makes a changing geography audible through rhythms, recorded voices and digital assembly.

      2:00