musicbriefs
1:58in production/ 1:58 · ceiling 15 min
Punk & post-punk

Metal Box

PiL give abrasive guitar and an unsettled voice a powerful bass-led structure.

Metal Box was released in 1979, named after the canister containing its original discs. It later appeared in conventional packaging as Second Edition. The music marks a substantial move beyond Public Image Ltd's debut, with several sessions and drummers contributing to its formation.

Worth your time?

Yes. Hear the whole thing.

What works
    What does not
      Hear it if
      • Listeners interested in dub-influenced post-punk and difficult textures
      Skip it if
      • Listeners seeking conventional choruses and warm vocal intimacy
      The written brief1 min read

      What the record is and where it came from

      Metal Box was released in 1979, named after the canister containing its original discs. It later appeared in conventional packaging as Second Edition. The music marks a substantial move beyond Public Image Ltd’s debut, with several sessions and drummers contributing to its formation.

      How it sounds, and how it was made

      Jah Wobble’s dub-influenced bass provides propulsion, while Keith Levene’s abrasive guitar and John Lydon’s cryptic vocal delivery resist easy accommodation. The parts do not simply reinforce one emotional gesture. Their different functions create a productive instability.

      What lands

      The bass gives the listener something physical to follow even when the guitar and voice become disorienting. That division of labour makes the record more than a rejection of conventional rock. It builds another workable relationship among the instruments.

      What does not

      The vocal manner and metallic textures can feel hostile over an extended listen. Listeners who depend on clear narrative lyrics or a resolving chorus may find little reassurance. The unusual packaging is also easier to describe than the music, and can become an unhelpful substitute for hearing it.

      The ideas inside it

      A stable foundation can support a deliberately unstable surface. The record’s force comes from allowing those conditions to coexist, rather than requiring every part to agree on how secure the music should feel.

      Who should hear it, and who should not

      Hear it if bass movement can keep you engaged through abrasive surroundings. It is less suitable when you want the voice to offer a welcoming centre.

      Is it worth your time

      Yes. Follow Wobble first, then listen to how Levene and Lydon complicate the ground he supplies. The relationships matter more than the container.

      Same genre · Punk & post-punk4 of 91
      2:00
      Public Image: First IssuePublic Image Ltd · 1978Public Image Ltd's debut was released in December 1978 after John Lydon's departure from the Sex Pistols. Keith Levene, Jah Wobble and Jim Walker formed the new band with him. The record makes its break with the prior group through musical priorities as well as personnel.
      1:58
      Crossing the Red Sea with the AdvertsThe Adverts · 1978The Adverts released Crossing the Red Sea in February 1978 after “No Time to Be 21” introduced the album as a single. John Leckie produced the Abbey Road recording. The debut places an established live-band format inside a focused studio presentation.
      10:34
      Ill CommunicationBeastie Boys · 1994Ill Communication is the Beastie Boys’ fourth studio album, co-produced by the band and Mario Caldato, Jr., recorded between 1993 and 1994 at Tin Pan Alley and G-Son Studios. It expands on their live-instrument approach begun with Check Your Head, incorporating hip-hop, punk rock, jazz, and funk, and reflects influences from Miles Davis’s On the Corner and Agharta. Contributions include live instrumentation from Money Mark, Eric Bobo, and Amery Smith, plus guest vocals from Q-Tip and Biz Markie. The 'Sabotage' backing track—built around MCA’s fuzzed and twangy bass—was laid down at Tin Pan Alley and sat unused for a year under the working title 'Chris Rock' before final vocals were added. The album was released on May 23, 1994, and received widespread critical acclaim for its stylistic range and synthesis of the group’s earlier impulses with matured musicianship and lyrical depth. Its artwork features a 1964 Bruce Davidson photograph and Alex Grey’s 'Gaia'.
      10:40
      Wowee ZoweePavement · 1995Wowee Zowee is Pavement’s third studio album, recorded in eleven spontaneous days at Easley Recording in Memphis — a studio familiar to some members from prior work with Silver Jews — with all five band members present for the first time. The sessions yielded numerous tracks, including re-recorded outtakes from Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain and long-standing live staples; Scott Kannberg sang his own compositions for the first time, encouraged by Stephen Malkmus. The band prioritised looseness and sprawl over cohesion, per Malkmus’ directive that 'the less it fits together, the better,' and immersed themselves in Memphis’ laid-back culture between takes. Final mixing and overdubbing occurred at Random Falls in Manhattan in February 1995. The album showcases experimental, eclectic songwriting — ranging from acoustic ballads to noise rock and punk — with lyrics oscillating between cryptic, humorous, and deliberately nonsensical, and marks Pavement’s longest studio release at nearly one hour, sequenced entirely by Malkmus across three vinyl sides (with side four left blank).
      Up next in Music

      The Moon & Antarctica

      Modest Mouse · 2000 · 1:58

      Modest Mouse use a larger recording budget to make their strange musical spaces more detailed.

      1:58