musicbriefs
SubjectsAll subjects on briefs.cloud →
Saved
Folk & singer-songwriter · Jazz

Eli and the Thirteenth Confession

Laura Nyro · 1968

A piano-led, string-draped, multi-tracked confession — not a sermon, not a show, but a room full of voices arguing with love.

Worth your time?4.5/5Yes.Hear the whole thing.What works, what does not, who it is for ↓
9:43in productionCh. 1 · One Voice, Many Layers/ 9:43 · ceiling 15 min
4 chapters · 9:43Ceiling 15:00

The brief is written and checked. The video joins this page when it is cut.4 chapters · 1 min read · 9:43 planned

Read the brief

Laura Nyro’s 1968 album Eli and the Thirteenth Confession is a densely layered, piano-driven work built from multi-tracked vocals, strings, and a rotating ensemble of session players. It merges pop form with avant-garde jazz sensibility and centres on themes of passion, love, death, and drugs. Widely regarded as one of her best works, it was written entirely by Nyro and arranged and co-produced by Charlie Calello.

Folk & singer-songwriterJazzAbstractionImprovisationLoveAbstraction across the network →
Chapters & takeaways4
  1. 1:09
    One Voice, Many Layers

    Nyro wrote every note and sang every voice — piano, harmonies, and all — while Charlie Calello shaped the arrangements.

  2. 2:33
    Pop Structure, Jazz Tension

    Multi-tracked vocals and strings fuse with avant-garde jazz to bend pop structure without breaking it.

  3. 3:42
    A Rotating Ensemble

    Acoustic and electric guitars, two bassists, drums, and vibes create a shifting instrumental floor — never locked in, always responsive.

  4. 6:00
    Praised, Not Predicted

    Critics praised its sophistication on release — not as prophecy, but as achievement.

1 more chapterFewer chapters
Running order13
  1. 01
    Luckie3:03
  2. 02
    Lu2:48
  3. 03
    Sweet Blindness2:42
  4. 04
    Poverty Train4:21
  5. 05
    Lonely Women3:36

    Heard in That Brennan Girl (1946)

  6. 06
    Eli’s Comin’4:00
  7. 07
    Timer3:26
  8. 08
    Stoned Soul Picnic3:50
  9. 09
    Emmie4:25
  10. 10
    Woman’s Blues3:49
  11. 11
    Once It Was Alright Now (Farmer Joe)3:01
  12. 12
    December’s Boudoir5:11
  13. 13
    The Confession2:49

Film placements are the ones described in each film's own entry, so the list is partial rather than complete.

Worth your time?

Yes. Hear the whole thing.

4.5/ 5
What works
  • multi-tracked vocals
  • strings
  • collision of gospel fervour and jazz harmony
  • ‘Eli’s Comin’’s piano-and-vocal intensity
What does not
  • establish a consistent rhythmic anchor
  • prioritise groove or repetition
  • maintain bassline continuity across tracks
  • use recurring drum patterns
Hear it if
  • people who want to hear how pop structure can hold avant-garde jazz, rich vocals, and inspired imagery
  • people who respond to vocal density over instrumental repetition
Skip it if
  • people who need steady tempo
  • people who require clear genre signposting
  • people who prefer minimal vocal layering
Who should hear it, and who should skipHide who it is for
The written brief1 min read

What the record is and where it came from

It is Laura Nyro’s 1968 sophomore album, written entirely by her, released by Columbia Records after she secured greater artistic freedom through a new contract.

How it sounds, and how it was made

It sounds like multi-tracked vocals layered over strings, piano, acoustic and electric guitars, bass guitar, drums, vibes, horns, and woodwinds. The arrangements merge pop structure with avant-garde jazz. Charlie Calello arranged and co-produced it. Laura Nyro played piano, keyboards, vocals, and harmonies. Chet Amsterdam played acoustic guitar and bass guitar. Ralph Casale played acoustic guitar. Hugh McCracken played electric guitar. Chuck Rainey played bass guitar. Artie Schroeck played drums and vibes. Roy Segal and Stan Tonkel engineered it.

What lands

The multi-tracked vocals land. The strings land. The collision of gospel fervour and jazz harmony lands. ‘Eli’s Comin’’s piano-and-vocal intensity lands. ‘Stoned Soul Picnic’’s vibraphone-and-voice interplay lands.

What does not

It does not establish a consistent rhythmic anchor. The arrangements prioritise vocal texture and harmonic density over groove or repetition. There is no bassline continuity across tracks — Chuck Rainey and Chet Amsterdam alternate, sometimes within a song — and no drum pattern recurs.

The ideas inside it

The themes are passion, love, romance, death, and drugs. The cover photography and perfumed lyric sheets reflect Nyro’s intentional, personal aesthetic.

Who should hear it, and who should not

People who want to hear how pop structure can hold avant-garde jazz, rich vocals, and inspired imagery should hear it. People who need steady tempo, clear genre signposting, or minimal vocal layering should not.

Is it worth your time

Yes. It is widely considered one of Laura Nyro’s best works. It received high critical praise for the depth and sophistication of its performance and arrangements.

Same genre · Folk & singer-songwriter4 of 174
10:50
Songs of Love and HateLeonard Cohen · 1971Songs of Love and Hate is Leonard Cohen’s third studio album, released in 1971. It follows Songs of Leonard Cohen (1967) and Songs from a Room (1969). It is part of his early sequence of folk music albums. Most of the album was recorded at Columbia Studio A in Nashville between 22 and 26 September 1970. 'Sing Another Song, Boys' was recorded live at the Isle of Wight Festival on 30 August 1970. Further recording took place at Trident Studios in London. Cohen reunited with producer Bob Johnston and brought back guitarist Ron Cornelius, who led the backing band called The Army. Cohen described 'Joan of Arc' as exploring how humans meet and embrace their destiny. He stated that 'Famous Blue Raincoat' is about a man writing to another man who had an affair with his wife, and that the title references his own blue Burberry raincoat. Cohen expressed dissatisfaction with 'Famous Blue Raincoat', feeling it was unfinished and revealed its compositional 'carpentry', though he praised its tune and some images. Cohen's syncopated classical guitar 'chop' is especially prominent on 'Avalanche', and he considered 'Dress Rehearsal Rag' unreperformable by him. Songs of Love and Hate was not referenced in the document as having been used in film soundtracks or performed on BBC TV.
10:18
Time Out of MindBob Dylan · 1997Time Out of Mind is a blues-inflected, atmospherically dense record made in Miami in January 1997. Its sound is defined by Daniel Lanois’ microphone techniques and strategic mixing — not by live-room realism. Dylan rewrote lyrics up to the first session and demoed songs in the studio, a rare move. Early blues artists guided its sonic palette. The album’s themes — bitter love, encroaching darkness — land with weight, not exposition. Its production choices bury the voice, reject clarity, and treat decay as material. It won Album of the Year at the Grammys, but its achievement is specific: it redefined how Dylan could sound, not how he should be heard.
8:39
Peter GabrielPeter Gabriel · 1977Peter Gabriel’s 1977 solo debut is a document of return—not reinvention. It bears the marks of a learning period: piano lessons, songwriting with Martin Hall, demos cut by end-1975. Recorded in Toronto with Bob Ezrin, it launched a series of four untitled albums, all ‘Peter Gabriel’, all Hipgnosis-designed. ‘Solsbury Hill’ anchors the record in place and autobiography—Solsbury Hill in Somerset. The rest floats, unmoored. No rhythm section dominates. No signature texture emerges. It is not cohesive. It is not polished. It is Gabriel, listening to himself again.
9:46
Sail AwayRandy Newman · 1972Sail Away is Randy Newman’s third studio album, released May 23, 1972, on Reprise Records, produced by Lenny Waronker and Russ Titelman. All songs were written by Newman, though several had been recorded earlier by others. The version of 'Last Night I Had a Dream' is a re-recording with a notably different arrangement. 'He Gives Us All His Love' first appeared in sparser, slower form for the 1971 film Cold Turkey. The album reached No. 163 on Billboard. The title track was later covered by Ray Charles and Linda Ronstadt.
Up next in Music

Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Rodgers and Hart Song Book

Ella Fitzgerald · 1956 · 10:18

This isn’t a tribute — it’s a takeover.

Next brief →Back to Folk & singer-songwriter
10:18