musicbriefs
9:56in productionCh. 1 · Transporterraum/ 9:56 · ceiling 15 min
Punk & post-punk · Rock

Is This It

A basement studio, 11 tracks, no reverb — this is what happens when a band refuses to let the studio add anything.

Is This It is a document of live-take discipline, recorded fast and lean in a basement studio with no embellishment. Its sound comes from where it was made, how many tracks were used, and who was in the room — not from myth, influence, or ambition beyond that room.

Chapters & takeaways4
  1. 1:04
    Transporterraum

    Recorded in a dim, basement studio in Manhattan’s East Village with no pretension and no overdubs.

  2. 2:16
    Retro-Futurism

    A sonic time machine: live takes shaped by pre-session listening, aiming for a past band in a future studio.

  3. 3:39
    Live Takes Only

    Built from a 14-song rehearsal set — most with different lyrics — refined into live takes, not edits.

  4. 5:27
    No Ego, Just Pro Tools

    Pro Tools used not for gloss but for grit — with a producer who brought no ego and only infrastructure.

Running order11
  1. 01
    Is This It2:35

    Heard in Meet Me in the Bathroom (2022)

  2. 02
    The Modern Age3:33
  3. 03
    Soma2:38
  4. 04
    Barely Legal3:58
  5. 05
    Someday3:07
  6. 06
    Alone, Together3:12

    Heard in About a Boy (2002)

  7. 07
    Last Nite3:18
  8. 08
    Hard to Explain3:48
  9. 09
    New York City Cops3:36
  10. 10
    Trying Your Luck3:28
  11. 11
    Take It or Leave It3:16

Film placements are the ones described in each film's own entry, so the list is partial rather than complete.

Worth your time?

Yes. Hear the whole thing.

4.5/ 5
What works
  • the live-take urgency of 'Last Nite', 'Soma', and 'The Modern Age'
  • the drum tone on 'Hard to Explain'
  • the vocal treatment on 'Someday'
  • the guitar amp placement on 'Barely Legal'
What does not
  • build on Gil Norton’s scrapped sessions
  • use more than 11 tracks per mix
  • feature 'When It Started' on the international version
  • include the North American sleeve image on that version
Hear it if
  • people who value fidelity to live performance over studio manipulation
  • people curious about how a raw, unembellished sound was achieved with digital tools in 2001
  • not people seeking narrative depth, sonic variation, or lyrical exposition
Skip it if
  • people seeking narrative depth
  • people seeking sonic variation
  • people seeking lyrical exposition
The written brief1 min read

What the record is and where it came from

The Strokes’ 2001 debut album. Recorded March–April 2001 at Transporterraum — a basement studio in Manhattan’s East Village — with Gordon Raphael. Built from a 14-song rehearsal set developed in 2000–2001.

How it sounds, and how it was made

It sounds like live takes cut in a basement studio with poor lighting but modern Pro Tools. Drum miking, guitar amp placement, and vocal treatment prioritise the band’s live dynamic. No more than 11 audio tracks were used per mix. Effects are restrained. The room is present — dry, close, unvarnished.

What lands

The live-take urgency of ‘Last Nite’, ‘Soma’, and ‘The Modern Age’. The drum tone on ‘Hard to Explain’. The vocal treatment on ‘Someday’. The guitar amp placement on ‘Barely Legal’. The absence of reverb, delay, or compression elsewhere.

What does not

It does not build on Gil Norton’s scrapped sessions. It does not use more than 11 tracks per mix. It does not feature ‘When It Started’ on the international version. It does not include the North American sleeve image on that version.

The ideas inside it

Urban youth navigating relationships in New York City. A retro-futuristic conceit: a band from the past making a record in the future. No mythmaking — just observation, repetition, and restraint.

Who should hear it, and who should not

People who value fidelity to live performance over studio manipulation. People curious about how a raw, unembellished sound was achieved with digital tools in 2001. Not people seeking narrative depth, sonic variation, or lyrical exposition.

Is it worth your time

Yes, if you want to hear how minimalism, live energy, and deliberate sonic economy sound when fused without compromise. No, if you expect polish, expansion, or elaboration.

Same genre · Punk & post-punk4 of 79
8:36
D.o.A. The Third and Final ReportThrobbing Gristle · 1978D.o.A. The Third and Final Report is Throbbing Gristle’s 1978 studio album, released on their own Industrial Records label as the follow-up to The Second Annual Report (1977) and the single 'United / Zyklon B Zombie'. It employs pre-recorded tape samples and self-modified effects units to produce a highly distorted sound, usually accompanied by spoken-word or lyrical delivery by Tutti or P-Orridge. The album builds on their transgressive and confrontational aesthetic.
9:21
Dear ScienceTV on the Radio · 2008Dear Science is TV on the Radio’s third studio album, recorded in 2008 at Stay Gold studio in Brooklyn. It is described as indie rock, art rock, funk, soul, and post-punk. Its title originated from a studio note by Dave Sitek: 'Dear Science, please start solving problems and curing diseases or shut the fuck up.' It was released on September 23, 2008.
9:10
Eternally YoursThe Saints · 1978Eternally Yours is The Saints’ 1978 second album, produced by Chris Bailey and Ed Kuepper, featuring an R&B-influenced sound with horn arrangements and new bassist Algy Ward. Recorded at Wessex Studios under the original title International Robots, the sessions yielded stripped-down versions later issued as bonus tracks. Bailey regarded it as the band’s first proper release—distinct from the demo character of their debut—though its horn-heavy approach reportedly alienated some listeners at the time. Retrospective assessments have elevated it as a punk classic, praised for consistency, variety, and influence, with endorsements from major musicians including Kurt Cobain and Mark Lanegan.
9:34
Germfree AdolescentsX‐Ray Spex · 1978Germfree Adolescents is X-Ray Spex’s 1978 debut album. All twelve tracks were written by Poly Styrene. Five had previously appeared on singles’ A-sides or B-sides. The core band was Poly Styrene (vocals), Jak Airport (guitar), Paul Dean (bass), Rudi Thomson (saxophone), and B.P. Hurding (drums). Rudi Thomson played saxophone on the album.
Up next in Music

It’s Too Late to Stop Now

Van Morrison · 1974 · 9:38

This isn’t a document of a great singer. It’s a document of a conductor who happens to sing.

9:38